Teach The Children Well

    Recently, a fair breeze and a beautiful day found me in New York City. It was a week or so before Halloween and since I am not a big fan of large holiday shopping crowds, I thought it might be my last chance to visit before I did some traveling and then having to put up with all hell breaking loose around the holidays. So, there I was, getting my bearings and deciding on a plan. Shall we?
    To be fair, I really just had one important goal: Visit the 9/11 Memorial. I had made it a point to go to the 25th Anniversary service at the 9/11 memorial site near my home in Bucks County. I have written about the memorial park which is truly a beautiful and respectful place, and the service for the 25th was wonderful. It then seemed only natural to head up to NYC and visit the memorial up there, as I had not yet seen it. I have been fortunate to visit a couple of our national memorials: The USS Arizona/Pearl Harbor Memorial in Hawaii, and The Holocaust Memorial in Washington, DC. They are both, in their own way...stunning and sad, and in a strange way...spiritually uplifting. I don’t mean that in any kind of normative religious sense, but in a way that says, we as a Nation honored and avenged the fallen, or played a significant part in doing so. Some of you might be a little taken aback at my language of vengeance; but I believe the law, whether local or international, makes no sense without the idea and language of vengeance. But intelligent people can argue about that another time. 
    So there I was, in this beautiful museum/memorial, guided by arrows/signs/and other visitors immediately down one of many escalators to what were the ground- and sub-ground floors. It was eerie seeing some of the original walls, as well as the huge circles of cement where the monstrous cylindrical columns that once held up these two frighteningly tall buildings once stood. Needless to say, it was incredibly overwhelming. You can then make your way to numerous presentation areas that break down every part of that fateful day, including a large, beautiful room with a photograph of every person that was murdered that day in New York. I will not attempt to describe all of it here, except to say that it is well worth the trip.
    Two things struck me, however. One is the difference between all of these memorials I have visited. They each have their own, I don’t know, vibe, as it were. The Holocaust Memorial is 5-6 hours of heavy, heavy silence. Not a word, or a whisper. And you leave feeling guilty that you are hungry and could use a bite to eat. The USS Arizona Memorial, on the other hand, is outside, surrounded by the beauty of Hawaii, and yet you are remembering every WWII movie you have ever seen, and people are respectful, yet quietly talking / whispering to one another. And you can’t shake the feeling that the dead are so much with you: Literally….because their graveyard is directly beneath the ocean waves. It is truly a beautiful, yet overwhelming experience.
    Now, because I’m a dork, The second thought / question I had, was, “How are we teaching the story of these events to the generation(s) that have been born after these events took place?” Don’t worry…for brevity’s sake, and the fact that I was just there, I’ll focus on the events of 9/11. 
    September 11, 2026, marked 25 years since al-Qaeda terrorists hijacked four commercial airliners and murdered nearly 3,000 innocent people in the deadliest terrorist attack in American history. So, when I arrived at the 9/11 memorial (under those same blue skies as there were 25 years ago), I was somewhat mesmerized at the new World Trade Center building. It is modern, stunning, and coupled with the beautiful pool and fountains out front, it truly is a sight to behold. A beautiful homage to its two predecessors. And as I stated above, the museum next door is equally impressive. 
    A generation of students has grown up with no memory of that day. What they understand about it depends on what we choose to teach them. Judging by some of the materials available, Americans should be concerned. And let me tell you why. 
    One of the nation’s most elite schools of education — the University of Pennsylvania Graduate School of Education — created “Teaching Beyond 9/11,” a “multimodal curriculum for high school and college educators,” whose title suggests a comprehensive treatment of the events. But its lessons devote only a paragraph to the attacks themselves. It says that the United States merely “accused” Osama bin Laden of masterminding them. It does not explain al-Qaeda’s responsibility or the Taliban’s role in sheltering the group.
    Meantime, the curriculum presents over 50 lessons about Islamophobia, racism, American power, and “social justice.” Students are encouraged to adopt political interpretations of the attacks and their aftermath and asked to identify “avenues for solidarity,” imagine “better futures,” and become motivated to act for social change. The curriculum includes a unit on “right-wing extremism” but offers no examination of Islamist extremism — the ideology that motivated the attack on America. And you people wonder why I fear for the future, and more and more parents are yanking their kids out of our public school systems. 
    This curriculum is promoted by NYC Public Schools, national education organizations, and state education departments in Oregon, Massachusetts, and Wisconsin, where it is recommended for middle school students. A quarter-century after 9/11, we are in danger of teaching young people more about America’s mistakes than about those who attacked us and what they believe.
    My own memory is as clear as the blue sky that morning. I was on my way to the office on I-95 listening to Imus In The Morning on WFAN out of New York. I have written of that morning and how the day unfolded. Feel free to read it here. 
    Most made it out of Lower Manhattan safely that day, but a few thousand did not. I don’t know about you, but I could not shake the memory of staring at the towers on television before they fell — and seeing thousands of sheets of paper fluttering in the air and people jumping to their deaths. The months that followed were filled with shock, devastation, and mourning. We learned of strangers who helped others escape the burning towers. An immediate sense of patriotism emerged; flags appeared everywhere. People gave blood, volunteered, and raised money for the families of the dead.
    The country knew exactly who had attacked us and why. There was no doubt that the terrorists chose not just high-casualty targets, but symbols of American commerce, prosperity, and freedom. They were adherents of an extreme Islamist ideology profoundly hostile to pluralism, religious liberty, democratic government, and the secular freedoms that Americans take for granted.
    We were told repeatedly, as though to explain the devastation and help ensure another attack would never happen, that our nation had suffered a “failure of the imagination” — we hadn’t taken precautions that we could have taken. Separated by an ocean from the world’s most violent conflicts, we didn’t think we were vulnerable.
    Today, every child sitting in a classroom deserves to understand the truth of what happened on 9/11 — who attacked us, and why. We fail to provide it at our peril.
    The attacks should be taught as an expression of an extremist political ideology that aims to destroy the United States and threatens freedom around the world. Students also need to understand what terrorism means. Extremists and their sympathizers increasingly describe terrorism as mere political “resistance,” as though the two terms were interchangeable. They are not.
    Terrorism is the deliberate targeting of innocent civilians to achieve a political, ideological, or religious objective. Students should understand the moral difference between those who deliberately target civilians and those acting to defend people from such attacks.
    Unfortunately, the Penn curriculum is just one example of curricula that downplay 9/11 history. A North American Values Institute (NAVI) review of other materials found a pattern of activist framing of the terrorist attacks that leaves children ignorant of the ideological forces that drove the attackers and steers them toward activism instead of understanding. One teaching guide, promoted by the National Education Association, the nation’s largest teachers’ union, encourages students to blame U.S. policy for 9/11 — for example, by asking “why some people hate the U.S. enough to kill thousands of people.” In a lesson on the American Federation of Teachers’ “Share My Lesson” platform, students read Osama bin Laden’s “Letter to America” uncritically and are asked only to summarize his arguments and find reasons for his anti-Semitism: “Why do you think Osama bin Laden hates Jews so much?” Really?
    Dangers to our free society still abound. We are more aware today than we were back then about perils from abroad. But we need to be clear-eyed about the threats at home, too, especially when our educational institutions are willing to distort history for ideological purposes.
    We can no longer safely assume that the truth of what happened on September 11, 2001, and why it matters, will make its way into American classrooms. Twenty-five years later, it is up to us to ensure that we do not suffer another failure of imagination. And again…make the trip if you can. It’s well worth it. 

Write to Peter: magtour@icloud.com

Comments

Popular Posts